Discussion about Judging
03-10-2013, 09:43 AM
Although taking size into account for fights would be more realistic, the problem is that it would be less fair, and eventually every wolf will be a 42" monster just so they can be able to compete in fights and players won't be able to have a wolf the size they want.
Our judging system now puts some weight into the player's writing skill with the Clarity category, I think, which makes it difficult for a less skilled writer to compete even if they're using a good strategy, so maybe weight could be taken away from writing skill, or maybe a less skilled writer could be given a handicap in fights so that they could win against a skilled writer so long as their strategy matches or exceeds the opponent's. But then again, this would discourage the players improving their skills...
Our judging system now puts some weight into the player's writing skill with the Clarity category, I think, which makes it difficult for a less skilled writer to compete even if they're using a good strategy, so maybe weight could be taken away from writing skill, or maybe a less skilled writer could be given a handicap in fights so that they could win against a skilled writer so long as their strategy matches or exceeds the opponent's. But then again, this would discourage the players improving their skills...